【The Twelve Factors of Dependent-Arising 希求解脱】 Qualm about two types of causality (1) 二重因果的问难I

【The Twelve Factors of Dependent-Arising】- Qualm about two types of causality (1)

If the latter,

The latter one is referring to two instances of causality.

there would be no ignorance, compositional activity, or causal period consciousness [projecting factors] in the latter cycle of causality [the ordering of projection], and no craving, grasping, or existence [actualizing factors] in the former cycle of causality [the ordering of actualization].

Yes! If you say that this is two instances of causality, the causes of the projection are ignorance, compositional activity and consciousness. Yes, the projected factors came from the projections of ignorance, compositional activity and consciousness. But for the latter cycle, it lacks ignorance, compositional activity and consciousness. That is why it says, "If the latter, there would be no ignorance, compositional activity, or causal period consciousness [projecting factors] in the latter cycle of causality [the ordering of projection]." This is one problem. "...and no craving, grasping, or existence [actualizing factors] in the former cycle of causality [the ordering of actualization]." In fact, what are the two instances?

SOURCE 来源 :

78B 22’12” Vol 10 of Master Jih-Chang’s Discourse P208 L7
English Lamrim Vol 1 P319

日常师父法语📡78B 22’12”手抄稿第10册P208 L7

希求解脱 : 二重因果的问难I

若如第二,

第二是说两重因果。

则后重因果中缺无明行及因位识,前因果中缺爱取有。

是啊!那你要两重因果的话,它这个引生的因是无明、行、识;是,前面是由无明、行、识引得来的;这后面第二次的话,那个无明、行、识就没有了,所以说“后重因果中缺了无明、行及因位识”,这是一个缺陷。“前因果中缺爱、取、有”,这么……前面实际上呢,它那个两重是什么呢?

Previous
Previous

【The Twelve Factors of Dependent-Arising 希求解脱】Qualm about two instances of causality II 二重因果的问难II

Next
Next

【The Twelve Factors of Dependent-Arising 希求解脱】One instance of causality” is unacceptable 重因果不合理