BW Monastery 吉祥宝聚寺

View Original

【The Origin of Suffering 希求解脱】How does the beings of the intermediate state move? 中有是怎么行走?

【The Origin of Suffering】- How does the beings of the intermediate state move?   

Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio

77A 08’05” Vol 10 of Lamrim Commentary P147 LL1 Master Jih-Chang’s Discourse

The Treasury of Knowledge Auto-commentary:532  

The three-humans, hungry ghosts, and animals-each move in their own way.

So the sutra said that The Treasury of Knowledge Auto- commentary offers an alternative.  It says that for [the beings of the intermediate state of] humans, hungry ghosts, and animals, they will move about like their own.  This means however the humans move about, the beings of the intermediate state with the shape of human will move about the same way.  This explanation is slightly different.   In brief, what this place is showing us again is that if there are differences between sutras and commentaries, he will cite them all, list them all here.  This is a unique feature!  This tells us, nah, a great master, a great noble being will reference the scriptures and the treatises.  He will never make a comment or a review without basis.  This further cautions us.  We would now casually read about something, and we would make a judgment to say it is this and it is that.  That should be very much prohibited.  

SOURCE 来源 :

77A 08’05” Vol 10 of Master Jih-Chang’s Discourse P147 LL1
English Lamrim Vol 1 P311

日常师父法语📡77A 08’05”手抄稿第10册P147 LL1

希求解脱 : 中有是怎么行走?

《俱舍论》说,人鬼畜三,各如自行。

这个是经上说的,那么这个《俱舍论》上面另外一种说法,说人、鬼、畜生,就像他,人当中怎么走,那个中有也是怎么走,这个说法有一点点不同。总之这个地方又告诉我们,他经跟论之间,如果彼此之间有不相应的地方,他统统俱引,引在那个地方。这个有一个特点哦!就告诉我们,喏,像这样的这种大成就者、大圣者,引经据典,但是他绝不自己轻下评论。这个又更要警策我们现在随随便便我们看了一点,根据我们的判断,说是这个、是这个、那个,这个是一个非常不应该做的事情。